How To Wear A Sweater With A Collared Shirt (5 Rules + 3 Outfits)

A sweater with a collared shirt is one of the easiest ways to look put-together when the weather turns cold. A navy crewneck over a light blue Oxford works at the office, on a date, and at Thanksgiving dinner. But most guys get the details wrong: the collar curls up over the neckline, three inches of shirttail hang out the bottom, and the whole thing bunches at the waist.

On the one hand, a collared shirt under a sweater gives you a polished and put-together look.

But on the other hand, it can also make you look old-fashioned and stuffy – two things that NO guy wants.

Below I’ll show you the four shirts that work best under a sweater, the sweater styles that work best over them, my five rules for getting the collar, cuffs, and hem right, and three complete outfits from casual to formal — so you look sharp without resembling your old grandpa. If you just want the answer, there’s a quick-reference chart in the rules section.

We’ll be covering:

1. What Collared Shirts Work Best With Men’s Sweaters?
   • Oxford Shirt
   • Chambray Shirt
   • Denim Shirt
   • Formal Collared Polo
2. Which Sweaters Work Best Over A Collared Shirt?
   • V-Neck Sweater
   • Crew Neck Sweater
   • Cardigan Sweater
   • Quarter-Zip And Shawl-Collar Cardigan
3. 5 Rules For Wearing A Sweater With A Collared Shirt
4. 3 Sweater And Collared Shirt Outfits (Casual To Formal)
   • The Casual Look: Cardigan Sweater, Shirt, and Jeans
   • The Smart-Casual Look: Crew Neck Sweater, Shirt, and Chinos
   • The Formal Look: V-Neck Sweater, Shirt and Trousers
5. Quick Answers: Collar In Or Out, Tucking, And Ties

What Collared Shirts Work Best With Men’s Sweaters?

When wearing a sweater with a collared shirt, the key to nailing a stylish and modern look is to pick the right shirt style. After all, some shirt styles are far more attractive than others, so choosing one that works well with your sweater is a must.

The shirt styles that work best with men’s sweaters are:

• The Oxford shirt
• The chambray shirt
• The denim shirt
• The Formal Collared Polo

Let’s take a closer look at each of these shirt styles so you can see why they work so well with sweaters.

Shirt #1 — The Oxford Shirt

One of the most popular shirt styles for men, the Oxford shirt is a wardrobe essential. It’s made from sturdy cotton fabric and typically features a button-down collar, making it the perfect shirt to wear with a sweater.

Not only does the Oxford shirt have a collar that won’t get lost under your sweater, but it also looks great when worn with a sweater. The shirt’s classic design makes it the perfect shirt to wear with a sweater, giving you a stylish and sophisticated look.

Shirt #2 — The Chambray Shirt

Another shirt style that works well with men’s sweaters is the chambray shirt. Chambray looks like denim from a few feet away, but it’s a lighter plain-weave cotton — softer, thinner, and much easier to layer under a knit without bulk. Most chambray comes in that faded blue, and that color is what sets it apart.

The blue color of the chambray shirt complements the colors of most men’s sweaters, giving you a stylish and modern look. And like the Oxford shirt, the chambray shirt typically features a collar that won’t get lost under your sweater.

Shirt #3 — The Denim Shirt

The denim shirt is another shirt style that looks great when worn with a men’s sweater. The denim shirt has a casual look that works well with most sweaters, giving you a relaxed and stylish look.

And like the Oxford and the chambray, the denim shirt has a sturdier collar that won’t go limp and hide under the neckline of your sweater.

Denim shirts are strictly a casual garment. After all, you wouldn’t wear a pair of jeans to the office, so don’t wear a denim shirt with your sweater to an important meeting or date.

Shirt #4 — The Formal Collared Polo

The last shirt style that works well with men’s sweaters is the formal collared polo. The formal collared polo shirt has a stylish and sophisticated look that makes it the perfect shirt to wear with a sweater.

The best thing about a formal collared polo is its versatility. They hold true to the casual nature of polo shirts in the body but elevate things a bit when it comes to the collar.

Similar to a poplin shirt, a formal collared polo shirt has a collar that’s designed to stay stiff and upright, making it the perfect shirt to wear with a sweater.

Which Sweaters Work Best Over A Collared Shirt?

Now that we’ve covered which shirt styles work best with men’s sweaters, it’s time to take a look at which men’s sweaters are best for a sweater and shirt combo.

The best sweaters for a sweater and shirt combo are:

• The V-neck sweater
• The crewneck sweater
• The cardigan sweater

Let’s take a closer look at each of these sweater styles so you can see why they work so well with shirts.

The V-Neck Sweater

The V-neck men’s sweater is a classic sweater style that’s been around for decades. It’s made from a variety of different materials, including wool, cotton, and cashmere.

The V-neck sweater has a timeless look that complements most shirt styles. And because the V-neck sweater exposes the neckline of your shirt, it’s the perfect sweater to wear with a shirt and tie combo.

For this style of jumper, I’d avoid wearing a chambray or denim shirt. The V-neck sweater reveals a lot of the shirt beneath it, meaning that the shirt’s collar and chest will be on full display.

Sweater Vests for Men: How to Wear One Without Looking Dated

And because chambray and denim shirts have a casual look, the texture and blue tones could overwhelm your outfit by making it look too busy.

Instead, opt for a shirt in a solid color or with a subtle pattern. A shirt in light blue or white will complement the V-neck sweater and give you a stylish and sophisticated look.

The Crewneck Sweater

The crewneck sweater is another classic sweater style that looks great when worn with a shirt. Like the V-neck sweater, the crewneck sweater is made from a variety of different materials, including wool, cotton, and cashmere.

The crewneck sweater has a timeless look that complements most shirt styles. And because the crewneck sweater covers the neckline of your shirt, it’s more versatile in the styles of shirts that it pairs with.

As less of the shirt shows, you can get away with wearing a shirt with a busier pattern or a more pronounced collar.

For this style of sweater, I would advise pairing it with either a formal collar polo shirt or an Oxford shirt. The sweater’s clean lines will complement the shirt’s collar and give you a stylish look.

The Cardigan Sweater

The last men’s sweater style that works great with a collared shirt is the cardigan sweater. The cardigan sweater is the stand-out of the three sweater styles as it’s an open garment that can be worn like a jacket (open or buttoned/zipped up).

As a result of this, it can meet the needs of both casual and formal environments depending on how you style it. This also means you can wear most shirt styles with this garment and still look well-styled and modern.

In formal environments, stick to wearing your cardigan sweater with an oxford shirt and tie. Doing this will keep the formality levels of your outfit high and ensure you look smart and stylish.

For a more casual sweater and shirt combo, consider pairing your cardigan sweater with a jean shirt.

The cardigan’s relaxed silhouette will complement the shirt’s casual style perfectly. And when worn with a pair of chinos, this combo will give you a stylish and effortless look.

The Quarter-Zip And Shawl-Collar Cardigan

Two more sweaters deserve a spot here. The quarter-zip sweater has become the default office layer for a lot of guys, and it was made for a collared shirt. Unzip it a few inches and the shirt collar sits right inside the knit’s stand collar, framed on both sides. Keep the collar points inside the zip opening, and stick with an Oxford, a fine stripe, or a structured-collar polo.

The shawl-collar cardigan is the heavyweight of the group. That thick rolled collar gives it some of the presence of a jacket, which is why it looks so good over an Oxford or a flannel shirt with dark jeans or chinos. Skip the tie with this one — the shawl collar and a tie compete for the same real estate.

5 Rules For Wearing A Sweater With A Collared Shirt

Picking the right shirt and the right sweater gets you most of the way there. The rest is in the details — and the details are what separate a sharp layered outfit from a 1990s school photo. Here are the five rules I follow every time.

Rule #1 — Keep The Collar Inside The Sweater

Your collar points go INSIDE the sweater’s neckline. With a V-neck, the points lie flat on either side of the V. With a crewneck, the collar band sits just inside the ribbing and the points tuck under it.

A dress shirt collar flipped out over a crewneck dates the whole outfit. If your collar points keep popping up and curling over the knit, the fix is a button-down collar — I break down the difference in my button-down vs point collar guide — or a shirt with stiff collar stays.

Rule #2 — Show About Half An Inch Of Cuff

Let ¼ to ½ inch of shirt cuff show past the sweater sleeve. Same rule as a suit jacket. It frames your hand and tells people there’s a real shirt under there, not a dickey.

If the sweater sleeves swallow the cuff completely, push them up a touch or take the sweater to your tailor — a good alterations shop can shorten the sleeves on a fine-gauge knit. If the shirt cuff hangs out an inch or more, your shirt sleeves are too long. That’s a shirt problem, not a sweater problem.

Rule #3 — Tuck The Shirt (Or Control The Hem)

For smart casual or anything dressier, tuck the shirt in. A tucked shirt lies flat under the knit and keeps your waist clean. The sweater stays out — I cover that side of it in should you tuck in your sweater.

Going casual with jeans? Untucked is fine IF the shirt is cut short enough. An inch of shirttail below the sweater hem looks deliberate. Three inches of dress-shirt tail flapping out the bottom looks like you got dressed in the dark. Long tails get tucked, period.

Rule #4 — Match The Knit Weight To The Shirt

Thin shirt, thin sweater. A crisp poplin or broadcloth dress shirt wants a fine-gauge merino, cotton, or cashmere sweater. Go thicker and the collar gets crushed and your torso looks inflated. Sturdier casual shirts — Oxford cloth, chambray, denim, flannel — can handle a mid-weight or even a chunky knit, because the fabric has enough body to hold its shape underneath.

Then check the fit. Shoulder seams should land on your shoulder bone, the hem should end around your belt line, and there should be just enough room that the shirt doesn’t bunch at your waist. Here’s a tip: try sweaters on with a collared shirt underneath. That’s how you’ll wear it, so that’s how you should buy it.

Rule #5 — One Pattern, Plenty Of Contrast

Keep it to one pattern. A gingham or striped shirt under a solid sweater works. A patterned shirt under a Fair Isle or a heavy cable knit fights for attention, and nobody wins.

Then go for contrast: a light shirt under a darker sweater. White or light blue under navy, charcoal, burgundy, or olive covers most of what you’ll ever need. A light grey sweater over a white shirt has almost no contrast and washes you out.

Match The Neckline To Your Build

Here’s the part most guides skip. A sweater’s neckline changes how your frame reads, so pick it on purpose. Not sure what build you are? Start with my male body shape guide, then use this:

• Shorter neck or rounder face: V-neck. The V draws the eye down and makes your neck look longer.
• Narrow shoulders or a slim build: crewneck. The horizontal line at the collarbone adds width across your chest. A mid-weight knit helps too.
• Broad chest or heavier build: a fine-gauge V-neck, or a flat-front cardigan worn open. Skip the chunky shawl collar — it adds bulk right where you don’t want it.
• Tall and lean: a shawl-collar cardigan or a textured crewneck. Both add some substance to a long frame.

And whatever your build, fit beats everything. A $60 merino crewneck that fits will look better than a $400 cashmere one hanging off your shoulders. If the body fits and only the sleeves are long, that’s a job for your tailor.

Here’s the whole thing on one screen:

3 Sweater And Collared Shirt Outfits (Casual To Formal)

Styling a shirt and sweater combo isn’t rocket science. However, there are a few things you need to keep in mind to ensure your outfit looks stylish and modern.

In this section, I’m going to share with you three shirt and sweater combo looks that will have you looking your best from the first cold morning in fall to the last one in spring.

The Casual Look: Cardigan Sweater, Shirt & Jeans

This is the most common way to style a shirt and sweater combo and is perfect for casual environments, such as going to the movies or out to lunch with friends.

To achieve this look, start by pairing a cardigan sweater with a shirt and jeans. The shirt can be any style you want, but I would advise sticking to a shirt in a solid color or with a subtle pattern or texture (like denim). This will ensure your outfit doesn’t look too ‘officewear’.

As for the jeans, I would recommend sticking to dark-wash jeans to complement the shirt and sweater. If you go with a denim shirt, make sure it’s a clearly different wash from your jeans. A light blue shirt over dark indigo jeans looks intentional — two matching blues look like a uniform.

Finish off the look with a pair of white dress sneakers for an informal finishing touch sure to bring your outfit to a stylish conclusion.

The Smart-Casual Look: Crew Neck Sweater, Shirt and Chinos

If you want to take your shirt and sweater combo up a notch, consider pairing your shirt with chinos instead of jeans. Doing this will immediately transform your outfit from casual to smart-casual.

For this look, start by pairing a crewneck sweater with a formal collar polo shirt and chinos (in a contrasting color to the sweater) just like you would with jeans. Tuck the polo shirt into the chinos to give your outfit a more polished look.

To finish off the outfit, consider adding a pair of loafers or Chelsea boots. These shoes will complement the smart-casual style of your outfit and ensure you look put-together from head to toe.

The Formal Look: V-Neck Sweater, Shirt, and Trousers

If you want to wear a shirt and sweater combo in a formal environment, consider pairing your shirt with trousers instead of jeans or chinos. Doing this will ensure your outfit looks sleek and stylish.

To achieve this look, start by pairing a V-neck sweater with an Oxford shirt, tie, and textured suit trousers (in a contrasting color to the sweater). The shirt should be tucked into the trousers as you would with a suit – and make sure you’re wearing a clean black/brown belt to bring the whole look together.

Should You Tuck in Your Sweater?

As for shoes, I would recommend sticking to dress shoes like Oxfords or Derbys. These shoes will complement the formality of your outfit and ensure you look smart and put-together.

Want to learn more about which shirt collar is right for you? Check out my guide here.

Sweater With Collared Shirt: Quick Answers

Should my shirt collar be in or out of my sweater?

In. The collar points tuck inside the neckline of a crewneck or lie flat inside a V-neck. A dress shirt collar flipped out over the top of a sweater looks dated. The one exception is a polo collar under an open cardigan or quarter-zip, which is designed to sit on top.

Do you tuck in a shirt under a sweater?

For smart casual and business casual, yes. Tuck the shirt, leave the sweater out. With jeans you can leave the shirt untucked, as long as no more than about an inch shows below the sweater hem.

Is a sweater over a collared shirt business casual?

Yes. A fine-gauge V-neck or crewneck over a dress shirt or Oxford, with chinos or wool trousers and leather shoes, is textbook business casual. I go deeper in my guide to wearing a sweater to work.

Can you wear a tie with a sweater?

Yes — with a V-neck or a cardigan, where the knot and a few inches of tie show. Use a smaller knot like the four-in-hand, and a wool or knit tie adds nice texture. Under a crewneck the tie disappears and leaves a lump, so it rarely works.

The post How To Wear A Sweater With A Collared Shirt (5 Rules + 3 Outfits) appeared first on Real Men Real Style.

View Original Source Here