‘Love Island USA’: Sydney and Isaiah’s romance threatened by new girl Phoebe

Reality TV

New Islanders mean new drama on “Love Island USA.”

After six women infiltrated Casa Amor, Isaiah Campbell’s head seems to be turning quite quickly for brunette bombshell Phoebe Siegel.

“I just, like, want a chance with you,” Siegel tells Campbell in Page Six’s exclusive preview of tonight’s shocking episode.  

Tempting Campbell away from his OG partner, Sydney Paight — and grazing her hand across the handsome model’s chiseled abs — Siegel adds, “Like, at the end of the day, I like you a lot.” 

Campbell then suggests that his chemistry with Siegel could cause his romance with Paight to combust. 

Sydney Paight and Isaiah Campbell on "Love Island USA" with an inset of Isaiah kissing Phoebe Siegel
Isaiah Campbell and Sydney Paight’s “Love Island USA” relationship is tested by Casa Amor bombshell Phoebe Siegel.
Casey Durkin/Peacock

“That spark that I have with you is different from Syd’s and I don’t know why,” he tells Siegel. “And I’m trying to figure out why.”

Unable to quell her physical attraction to Campbell, Seigel asks, “Are you gonna kiss me now?”

Almost immediately, the pair launch into a steamy makeout session. 

Phoebe Siegel and Isaiah Campbell on "Love Island USA"
Campbell tells Siegel their connection is “different” than the one he shares with Paight.
Peacock

Meanwhile, back at the villa, Paight tells her pal Zeta Morrison that she is ready to take her relationship with Campbell to the next level.  

“Like, when he comes home, I’m just going to tell him my truest feelings and be like, ‘I really like you, like can we date?’” she reveals, unaware that Campbell is cracking on with another girl at Casa Amor. 

“Date? You’re gonna ask him to be your boyfriend?!” Morrison asks, clearly thrilled at the prospect of Paight and Campbell making things official. 

Sydney Paight on "Love Island USA"
Back at the villa, Paight shares her plan to ask Campbell to be her boyfriend.
Peacock

The redheaded beauty then explains why she is ready to commit. “It’s, like, my heart, I can feel, like, the radio-activeness,” she gushes. “Like, my vibe and his shooting up into the sky and intertwining.”

Though Paight and Campbell have experienced their fair share of ups and downs on “Love Island USA” — their journey marked by an intoxicating mixture of passion and jealousy — they have been considered frontrunners to win the season.

In exclusive interviews with Page Six, recent castoffs Sereniti Springs and Andy Voyen shared their thoughts on Paight and Campbell possibly taking home the title of “America’s Favorite Couple” and its accompanying $100,000 prize. 

Phoebe Siegel and Isaiah Campbell on "Love Island USA"
Paight is unaware that Campbell is cracking on with another girl behind her back.
Casey Durkin/Peacock

“We love a toxic love story!” Springs explained with a laugh. “I don’t really know if I could endure in that, but that’s what happens when you put … a redhead and a guy with a dangly earring [together], it’s screaming toxic.”

She elaborated, “But that’s the thing, they love having that, going back and forth … It’s sexy to them. They’re like, ‘Oh yes, baby!’”

For his part, Voyen expressed concern for Paight and Campbell. 

Isaiah Campbell and Sydney Paight on "Love Island USA"
Up until now, Campbell and Paight have been considered one of the strongest couples on this season of “Love Island USA.”
Casey Durkin/Peacock

“I do feel like he might venture out and look at other possibilities, which might end up hurting Sydney and Isaiah’s relationship a little bit,” he told us. “We’re going to find out. I’m not exactly sure. But I got Timmy [Pandolfi] and Zeta as top dogs right now.”

“Love Island USA” — hosted by Sarah Hyland — is available to stream on Peacock. New episodes drop Tuesday through Sunday at 9 p.m. ET. 

Articles You May Like

Jared Leto Playing Skeletor in Live Action ‘Masters of the Universe’
An In-Depth Guide to Double-Breasted Suits
Audiobook review of Lifeform by Jenny Slate
‘The Housemaid’ Starring Sydney Sweeney Releasing Christmas 2025
Spanish brand Bimba Y Lola debuts on ASOS