Peter Weber: why my ‘difficult’ Madison Prewett romance didn’t work out

Reality TV

Peter Weber is aware that there were thorns in his “Bachelor” romance with Madison Prewett. 

“It was literally the most trying and most difficult experience I have ever been through,” Weber, 30, exclusively told Page Six in a new interview, reflecting on his time leading Season 24 of the ABC dating series — and courting Prewett — in 2020. 

As viewers will recall, Weber instantly connected with Prewett, 25, who received his first one-on-one date — an intimate visit to the pilot’s family home in Southern California to attend his parents’ vow renewal. 

The Alabama-bred contestant, who told Weber that she was saving herself for marriage earlier in the season, eventually made it to Fantasy Suites week — but fled the show after learning that her then-potential husband had been intimate with his other two finalists. 

Madison Prewett abd Peter Weber
Peter Weber exclusively told Page Six why his “Bachelor” love story with Madison Prewett didn’t end happily ever after.

“As much respect for her as I have and think so highly of her, I definitely see there were differences between the two of us that probably weren’t going to allow a meaningful long-term relationship to flourish,” Weber said. “Nothing against either one of us. It’s just who we are. It is what it is.” 

Weber isn’t sure that his love story with Prewett would have ended happily ever after even if she had received the first date of the week, which many fans have claimed would have given the proud Christian an opportunity to underline her morals.

“If that would have been the case, obviously the show probably would have gone a little different,” Weber said. “But truly, I really mean this, I don’t know if that would have changed anything in the long run.”

Peter Weber and Madison Prewett
Prewett received Weber’s first one-on-one date of Season 24 in 2020.
Instagram

Prewett echoed as much in a recent interview with Page Six, saying,  “At the end of the day, it is what it is and it all happened the way that it was supposed to.”

After Prewett called it quits with Weber, he ultimately proposed to final rose recipient Hannah Ann Sluss. But when that engagement crumbled, Weber and Prewett made a pact at the “After the Final Rose” special to explore their relationship off-camera.

Days later, though, the star-crossed couple, who also faced criticism from Weber’s opinionated mother, Barbara, parted ways for good

Prewett details her “tortuous” split from Weber in her new memoir, “Made for This Moment: Standing Firm with Grace, Strength and Courage” — a book he has yet to read, though he supports her literary endeavors.  

“I’ve got nothing but great things to say about her,” he said. “She’s always carried herself in the best way possible. I’m excited to see all her success that she’s accomplished.” 

Weber, who also dated “Bachelor” Season 24 star Kelley Flanagan post-show, told us that he hasn’t maintained friendships with any of his reality TV exes — and is intrigued by the idea of dating someone who isn’t famous. 

Peter Weber and Madison Prewett
The pair’s relationship dissolved after Prewett learned that Weber had been physically intimate with his other two finalists.
Instagram

“I really am more of a private person. I know a lot of people don’t believe that but I really am,” he said. “I look forward to possibly dating someone that’s not in the public eye. To me, there’s something that’s just very attractive about that and just keeping things a little bit closer to the chest.” 

But if he’s still single by next summer, Weber is open to looking for love on the beaches of “Bachelor in Paradise.”

“That’s obviously the one avenue I haven’t gone down, but it’s the one that I think could work better for me than ‘The Bachelorette’ or ‘The Bachelor,’” said the “Bachelorette” Season 15 alum, who previously competed for Hannah Brown’s heart in 2019. 

Weber — who was unable to participate in the spin-off this year due to scheduling conflicts — elaborated, “Just being able to focus on one person is how I really kind of like vibe with someone and connect. Having so many people around and having so many women to navigate through, it can be distracting. So I like the thought of how ‘Paradise’ is run.”

Articles You May Like

Warner Bros. Developing a New Version of 1950s Sci-fi Classic ‘Forbidden Planet’
Charlamagne Tha God misgendered Caitlyn Jenner while slamming her lack of support for trans people
James Patterson Shares Love For Tyler Perry, Explaining Why He Thinks Star ‘Got Screwed By The Director’ Of Alex Cross Movie
We’re All Talking About My Old Ass’ Twist, But I Think There’s Way More To Say About How It Captures Being A Teen And A Grownup
Gillian Welch and David Rawlings Announce 2025 Tour